Skip to main content

Supplements

What's worth your money. What isn't.

Food first, test the gap, then supplement the gap. A mega-dose of calcium isn't better and may have downsides. Nila doesn't sell a supplement, a drug or a clinic, so we can tell you the truth about supplements and the wellness grift. No affiliate links, ever. Sponsorship never shapes what lands where on this page.

Start here

Three takeaways, free, no login.

Tap a card to save it on this device. Nothing leaves your phone or computer.

  • Read the bone health guide
  • See the movement guide
  • Browse the research library

The graded list

Every row free. Trust is the free value.

Name, grade, sample size, who funded it, the plain takeaway, and the interaction to flag with a pharmacist. Nothing on this list is locked.

Worth it if there's a gap

  • Vitamin D

    Grade B
    Sample
    n=36,282 (WHI trial)
    Funding
    US National Institutes of Health

    Reasonable if your intake or tested level is low, especially paired with calcium for bone. Testing first beats guessing.

    Interaction flag: High doses can raise calcium too far; flag if you have kidney stones.

    SOGC guideline 422a (2024)
  • Calcium (only if intake is low)

    Grade B
    Sample
    n=36,282 (WHI trial)
    Funding
    US National Institutes of Health

    Food first. Supplement only the gap between what you eat and what you need. Mega-doses aren't better and may carry downsides.

    Interaction flag: Can block thyroid medication absorption; take hours apart.

    SOGC guideline 422a (2024)
  • Creatine

    Grade B
    Sample
    n=608 (7 trials, 2026 meta-analysis)
    Funding
    Academic; two senior authors have creatine-industry ties

    Monohydrate plus resistance training gave small gains in muscle and leg strength at trial doses of 5 g a day or more. Without training, no measurable effect, and bone density didn't change. A muscle finding, not a bone, sleep or brain-fog one.

    Interaction flag: Kidney indices didn't change in trials, which excluded kidney disease; flag it if that's you.

    JISSN meta-analysis (2026)

Mixed or thin evidence

  • Magnesium (for sleep)

    Grade C
    Sample
    Small trials in older adults, not menopause-specific
    Funding
    Mixed, some industry

    May help you fall asleep a little faster if you're low. Low to very low certainty, and no form is proven superior. Not a hot-flash, weight or brain-fog treatment.

    Interaction flag: Can loosen stools at higher doses; separate from thyroid medication.

    Mah and Pitre, systematic review (2021)
  • Omega-3 (for mood)

    Grade C
    Sample
    n=1,000+ pooled, heterogeneous
    Funding
    Mixed academic and industry

    Some signal for mood in pooled trials, but studies differ wildly in dose and quality. Food sources first is the safer bet.

    Interaction flag: High doses can thin blood, and high doses in people with heart disease carry a modest heart-rhythm signal; flag either with your prescriber.

    NAMS nonhormone position (2023)
  • Creatine (for mood)

    Grade C
    Sample
    n=1,093 (11 trials, 2025 meta-analysis)
    Funding
    Not stated in the review abstract

    A small average lift in depression scores, below what usually counts as clinically meaningful, with very low certainty. Studied mainly as an add-on to prescribed care, and not in menopause. In older adults, strength training moved mood; creatine alone didn't.

    Interaction flag: If you take an antidepressant, raise it with your prescriber first; flag kidney disease.

    Br J Nutr meta-analysis (2025)
  • Black cohosh

    Grade C
    Sample
    n=1,000+ across inconsistent trials
    Funding
    Largely industry

    Trials are inconsistent and products vary a lot. NAMS doesn't recommend it over placebo for hot flashes.

    Interaction flag: Rare liver injury reports; avoid with liver conditions.

    NAMS nonhormone position (2023)
  • Spirulina

    Grade C
    Sample
    Small, short trials only
    Funding
    Often supplement companies

    Small trials hint at modest cholesterol and blood sugar changes, but NCCIH finds too little evidence for any condition. On top of a multi it adds little, and its B12 is mostly a form the body can't use.

    Interaction flag: Can carry liver toxins (microcystins) or heavy metals, so pick third-party-tested products. May stimulate the immune system: check first with autoimmune conditions or immune-suppressing medicines.

    NCCIH: Blue-green algae
  • Chlorella

    Grade C
    Sample
    Very few, small human trials
    Funding
    Often supplement companies

    Even less human research than spirulina. Nothing shows a benefit beyond what a multivitamin and a varied diet already give you.

    Interaction flag: Can be high in vitamin K (raise it if you take warfarin) and iodine (raise it if you have a thyroid condition).

    NIH ODS: Vitamin K fact sheet

Marketing only

  • "Menopause blend" combos

    Grade D
    Sample
    No meaningful trials
    Funding
    Sold by the brands themselves

    Proprietary blends with a dozen ingredients at untested doses. You're paying for the label, not the evidence.

    Interaction flag: Unknown, because the doses are undisclosed. That's the problem.

    NAMS nonhormone position (2023)
  • Detox and cleanse products

    Grade D
    Sample
    No trials
    Funding
    Sold by the brands themselves

    Your liver and kidneys already detox you. No trial has ever shown a cleanse does anything a healthy body doesn't.

    Interaction flag: Some laxative-based products interfere with medication absorption.

    NAMS nonhormone position (2023)
  • Collagen pills for skin

    Grade D
    Sample
    n=1,474 (23 trials, 2025 meta-analysis)
    Funding
    Mostly industry-funded

    Pooled trials looked positive, but studies without industry funding, and the high-quality ones, showed no significant effect on skin. Unproven for hair, and not a bone treatment.

    Interaction flag: Low risk, low reward.

    Am J Med meta-analysis (2025)

Interaction checker

Check one, free.

Pick what you're taking and see what on the list bumps into it. One check is free, on this device. The full checker, across everything you take, is part of Premium.

Pick a medication above and the flags open here.

Free · private worksheet

Before you add anything to the cabinet.

Tick what you're taking or considering. Add the rest of your list and the questions you want answered. This isn't a complete medication review or a statement that a combination is safe.

Taking or considering

Nothing here is saved or sent to Hello Nila. Copying puts your list on your device's clipboard.

Read the fuller supplements and treatment guide

Before you buy a "menopause" blend

Read the label, not the name

In 2026, the UK consumer group Which? reviewed 26 supplements sold for perimenopause and menopause. None had the right nutrients at doses worth taking, so none earned its top rating.

  • Watch for "fairy-dusting." An ingredient can be on the label at a dose far too small to do anything; one blend had 100 mg of evening primrose oil, against a usual 500 mg.
  • The opposite problem happens too: too much. Vitamin B6 is added to many blends, multis and energy products at once, so totals stack up without anyone noticing. Long-term high-dose B6 from supplements can cause sensory nerve damage: tingling, numbness, pain in hands and feet, and in severe cases difficulty walking. The US upper limit for adults is 100 mg a day, and EFSA, Europe's food safety authority, set a much lower adult upper limit in 2023 after reports of nerve symptoms at lower doses. If B6 is in more than one product, add it up and raise the total with a pharmacist.
  • Calcium and vitamin D are what usually matter for bones. 20 of the 26 had no calcium at all, and some had a fraction of the 10 micrograms of vitamin D the NHS suggests.
  • "Natural" isn't the same as safe. Black cohosh didn't beat placebo for hot flashes in a Cochrane review, and rare liver injury has been reported. Herbs can also interact with medicines, so check with a pharmacist.
  • Gummies leave little room for the active ingredients, because sugars and gelling agents take up the space.
  • In the UK: the blends cost up to about £485 a year, against about £22 for a basic multivitamin.

If you take a multivitamin

A basic multi is a reasonable way to cover gaps. It won't prevent heart disease or cancer, according to the US Preventive Services Task Force. What to look for:

  • Vitamin D at a useful dose, at least 10 micrograms (400 IU). Many people need more in winter, so ask your doctor or pharmacist.
  • Vitamin B12. Absorption from food drops with age, and the form in supplements is easy to absorb.
  • Little or no iron once periods have stopped, unless you've been told you're low. Formulas labelled "50+" usually reflect this.
  • Don't count on it for calcium. Multis carry only a small amount, because calcium is bulky.
  • Nothing far above 100% of daily values, especially B6, vitamin A and iron, and check whether your other products repeat the same nutrients.
  • A quality mark. In Canada, look for an NPN on the label. Third-party seals such as USP or NSF mean the contents were tested against the label.
  • Algae powders like spirulina and chlorella add little on top of a multi, and their B12 is mostly a form the body can't use.

Fewer bottles, fewer missed doses. A weekly pill organizer with morning and evening slots, filled once on a Sunday, means you only open one thing each day. Bring the bottles, not the organizer, to a pharmacist when you want everything checked for overlaps.

Sources
  1. Which? (2026). Why menopause supplements aren't worth it. Consumer investigation, not a study.
  2. Leach MJ, Moore V (2012). Black cohosh for menopausal symptoms. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.
  3. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Black cohosh fact sheet (liver safety).
  4. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Vitamin B6, Health Professional Fact Sheet (adult upper limit 100 mg/day; sensory neuropathy with chronic high-dose use). EFSA's 2023 adult upper limit noted as a contrast.
  5. NHS. Vitamin D (10 micrograms a day guidance).
  6. US Preventive Services Task Force (2022). Vitamin, mineral and multivitamin supplements for the primary prevention of cardiovascular disease and cancer. JAMA.
  7. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Multivitamin/mineral supplements fact sheet.
  8. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Vitamin B12 fact sheet (absorption from food falls with age; B12 analogues in algae).
  9. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Iron fact sheet (lower needs after periods stop).

Free and Premium

Free on this page. Structured in Premium.

Free, on this device

  • The full graded list, every row, no login
  • The three takeaways, saved on this device
  • One interaction check, on this device

Premium

  • Track what you take against your symptom patterns, week by week
  • The full interaction checker across everything you take
  • A doctor-ready list you can hand over at an appointment
Track what I'm taking, try Premium free

The evidence

Graded, dated, funding shown.

  • Grade A

    NAMS nonhormone therapy position statement (2023)

    The reference point for what actually has evidence for hot flashes beyond hormones, and what doesn't.

    Read the source
  • Grade B

    SOGC guideline 422a: menopause and bone (2024)

    Canadian guideline covering calcium, vitamin D and bone protection through the transition.

    Read the source
  • Grade B

    AHA science advisory on midlife health (El Khoudary, 2020)

    Frames the transition as a window where nutrition and movement choices compound, for heart and bone.

    Read the source
  • Grade C

    Individual supplement trials

    Where a trial was funded by the company selling the product, we say so on the row and grade accordingly.

    Read the source
Open the research library

One more time, gently.

We're an older sister with reading glasses on, not your doctor. Supplements bump into medication, conditions, and each other in ways that aren't always obvious. Anything here is a starting point for a conversation with your doctor or pharmacist, not a replacement for what they've already prescribed you.

Sources

The evidence behind this page.

Including the places where the honest answer is “the evidence is thin”. See how we grade evidence.

Creatine and cognition: promising, still being studied

2 sources

Show

Evidence for strength alongside resistance training doesn't automatically establish a benefit for menopause brain fog.

Creatine and cognitive function in adults: systematic review and meta-analysis

Systematic reviewFrontiers in Nutrition · 2024

Sixteen randomized trials involving 492 adults found modest memory benefits and improvements on some timed tasks, but no significant improvement in overall cognition or executive function. These weren't menopause-specific trials. All used creatine monohydrate; certainty was moderate for memory and low for other outcomes.

Read the source

CONCRET-MENOPA: an eight-week creatine trial in perimenopause and menopause

Randomised trialKorovljev et al · Journal of the American Nutrition Association · 2025

A small trial of 36 participants found improved reaction time and increased frontal brain creatine with the medium-dose hydrochloride group compared with placebo. It lasted eight weeks and tested creatine hydrochloride and ethyl ester, not standard monohydrate. Partly industry-funded by Vireo Systems, which supplied the products. It doesn't establish a treatment for everyday menopause brain fog or superiority over monohydrate.

Read the source

The position statements behind every grade on this page

4 sources

Show

We don't sell supplements, so we can be blunt: most of this category is under-evidenced, and these are the documents that say so.

Cognitive behavioural therapy and clinical hypnosis are the non-hormone approaches with enough evidence to be recommended for vasomotor symptoms. Most supplements, and several popular practices, aren't.

Clinical guidelineThe Menopause Society — 2023 nonhormone therapy position statement · 2023

The single most useful document for separating 'has trials' from 'has marketing'.

Read the source

The UK's national guideline sets out what's and isn't supported for menopause symptoms, including its position on complementary therapies and unregulated preparations.

Clinical guidelineNICE NG23 — Menopause: identification and management · 2024
Read the source

Nutrition, activity, alcohol, smoking and weight are addressed as first-line levers for vasomotor symptoms in Canada's national menopause guideline — with realistic expectations of how much they move the needle.

Clinical guidelineSOGC Clinical Practice Guideline No. 422a — VMS, therapeutics, CAM, nutrition and lifestyle · 2024
Read the source

Weight-bearing and resistance exercise sit inside the standard framework for postmenopausal bone health — alongside calcium, vitamin D and, where fracture risk is high, medication.

Clinical guidelineThe Menopause Society — 2021 osteoporosis position statement · 2021

Also the honest source on what exercise alone can't do once bone loss is established.

Read the source

How thin the evidence base actually is

1 sources

Show

Someone finally counted. Twenty-five years of US supplement research on menopause, mapped ingredient by ingredient — and perimenopause is barely in it.

Two decades of US dietary-supplement research on menopause adds up to only 253 experimental studies, spread across more than 80 different ingredients — and almost all of it (n = 234) looks at postmenopause, not perimenopause.

Systematic reviewCanino et al. — Menopause (journal of The Menopause Society), bibliometric analysis 2000–2024 · 2026

Annual growth in this literature is 3.89%. Calcium, vitamin D and isoflavones are the only ingredients studied often enough to replicate — which is why most of the shelf below grades low.

Read the source